Opinion: The Republican blueprint to steal the 2024 election

Fewer nonetheless understand why previous President Donald Trump and Republicans persist in their lengthy-disproven assert that the 2020 presidential election was stolen. Significantly fewer why they are obsessed about generating the 2024 race a referendum on the “stolen” election of 2020, which even they know was not stolen.

January 6 was hardly ever about a stolen election or even about real voting fraud. It was normally and only about an election that Trump lost good and square, underneath legislatively promulgated election guidelines in a handful of swing states that he and other Republicans contend ended up unlawfully transformed by point out election officials and condition courts to grow the suitable and opportunity to vote, mostly in reaction to the Covid pandemic.

The Republicans’ mystifying assert to this day that Trump did, or would have, been given much more votes than Joe Biden in 2020 ended up it not for true voting fraud, is but the shiny item that Republicans have tauntingly and disingenuously dangled ahead of the American public for practically a year and a fifty percent now to distract awareness from their far much more bold aim.

That objective is not by some means to rescind the 2020 election, as they would have us think. Which is constitutionally not possible. Trump’s and the Republicans’ significantly far more formidable aim is to execute correctly in 2024 the incredibly exact same strategy they failed in executing in 2020 and to overturn the 2024 election if Trump or his anointed successor loses again in the future quadrennial contest.

The previous presidential election was a dry operate for the next.

From long in advance of Election Working day 2020, Trump and Republicans planned to overturn the presidential election by exploiting the Electors and Elections Clauses of the Structure, the Electoral University, the Electoral Rely Act of 1877, and the 12th Amendment, if Trump dropped the well-known and Electoral Faculty vote.

The cornerstone of the program was to have the Supreme Courtroom embrace the tiny acknowledged “impartial point out legislature” doctrine, which, in flip, would pave the way for exploitation of the Electoral College or university course of action and the Electoral Depend Act, and lastly for Vice President Mike Pence to reject enough swing state electoral votes to overturn the election utilizing Pence’s ceremonial electrical power less than the 12th Modification and award the presidency to Donald Trump.

The independent condition legislature doctrine claims that, beneath the Elections and the Electors Clauses of the Constitution, point out legislatures have plenary and exceptional energy more than the perform of federal presidential elections and the collection of condition presidential electors. Not even a point out supreme court, permit by yourself other state elections officers, can alter the legislatively written election principles or interfere with the appointment of state electors by the legislatures, less than this theory.

The Supreme Court docket has never decided regardless of whether to embrace the unbiased condition legislature doctrine. But then-Main Justice William Rehnquist, and Justices Antonin Scalia and Clarence Thomas in independent concurring viewpoints said they would embrace that doctrine in Bush v. Gore, 20 decades previously, and Republicans had each purpose to feel there ended up at least five votes on the Supreme Courtroom for the doctrine in November 2020, with Amy Coney Barrett possessing just been verified in the eleventh hour right before the election.

Opinion: McCarthy and McConnell's U-turn on Trump shows extent of GOP's partisan rot

Trump and the Republicans started executing this first stage of their approach months just before November 3, by tough as violative of the independent condition legislature doctrine election policies relating to early- and late-voting, extensions of voting times and moments, mail-in ballots, and other election legislation modifications that Republicans contended had been unlawfully altered by state officers and state courts in swing states these types of as Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, North Carolina and Michigan.

These instances eventually wound their way to the Supreme Courtroom in the drop of 2020, and by December, the Supreme Court experienced made the decision all of these circumstances, but only by orders, possibly disallowing federal court docket intervention to change an election rule that experienced been promulgated by a point out legislature, allowing for legislatively promulgated rules to be altered by point out officers and point out courts, or deadlocking 4-4, simply because Justice Barrett was not sworn in right until immediately after those people conditions had been briefed and all set for choice by the Court docket. In none of these cases did the Supreme Court docket make a decision the all-vital unbiased point out legislature doctrine.

Thwarted by the Supreme Court’s indecision on that doctrine, Trump and the Republicans turned their initiatives to the 2nd stage of their plan, exploitation of the Electoral College and the Electoral Rely Act.

The Electoral School is the course of action by which Us residents pick out their presidents, a course of action that can guide to the election as president of a candidate who does not receive a bulk of votes solid by the American voters. Republicans have developed progressively wary of the Electoral University with the new census and political demographics of the nation’s shifting inhabitants.

Opinion: Gerrymandering on steroids is the new normal

The Electoral Count Act empowers Congress to determine the presidency in a host of conditions exactly where Congress establishes that point out electoral votes have been not “frequently offered” by electors who were being “lawfully qualified,” conditions that are undefined and ambiguous. In this 2nd stage of the approach, the Republicans necessary to crank out point out-licensed substitute slates of electors from swing states where Biden gained the popular vote who would forged their electoral votes for Trump as an alternative. Congress would then count the votes of these different electoral slates on January 6, relatively than the votes of the licensed electoral slates for Biden, and Trump would be declared the reelected president.

The Republicans’ strategy unsuccessful at this stage when they had been unable to secure a solitary reputable, alternate slate of electors from any state due to the fact the a variety of condition officials refused to officially certify these Trump-urged slates.

Thwarted by the Supreme Court docket in the initially stage, foiled by their incapacity to come up with alternate condition electoral slates in the second stage, and with time working out, Trump and the Republicans started executing the final choice in their plan, which was to scare up illegitimate alternative electoral slates in various swing states to be transmitted to Congress. Whereupon, on January 6, Vice President Pence would depend only the votes of the illegitimate electors from the swing states, and not the votes of the respectable, qualified electors that ended up cast for Biden, and declare Donald Trump’s reelection as President of the United States.

Opinion: This trend imperils the future of liberalism, democracy and capitalism

The total house of playing cards collapsed at noon on January 6, when Pence refused to go alongside with the ill-conceived prepare, accurately concluding that under the 12th Amendment he had no electrical power to reject the votes that experienced been forged by the duly accredited electors or to delay the depend to give Republicans even much more time to whip up substitute electoral slates.

Pence declared Joe Biden the 46th President of the United States at 3:40 a.m. on Thursday, January 7, about 14 hrs following rioters stormed the US Capitol, disrupting the Joint Session and avoiding Congress from counting the Electoral University votes for president until eventually late that evening and into the next working day, just after the statutorily selected day for counting people votes.

Trump and his allies and supporters in Congress and the states started readying their failed 2020 plan to overturn the 2024 presidential election later on that quite identical day and they have been unabashedly readying that strategy ever since, in plain view to the American community. Now, they are currently a very long way towards recapturing the White Dwelling in 2024, no matter whether Trump or an additional Republican applicant wins the election or not.

Trump and Republicans are planning to return to the Supreme Court, in which this time they will possible get the independent state legislature doctrine, now that Amy Coney Barrett is on the Courtroom and prepared to vote. Barrett has not resolved the difficulty, but this turns on an originalist interpretation of the Constitution, and Barrett is firmly aligned on that system of constitutional interpretation with Thomas, Alito, and Gorsuch, all 3 of whom have written that they consider the doctrine is right.

Only very last thirty day period, in a circumstance from North Carolina the Court docket declined to listen to, Moore v. Harper, four Justices (Alito, Thomas, Gorsuch and Kavanaugh) stated that the independent state legislature query is of extraordinary great importance to our national elections, the problem will carry on to recur and the Court docket need to determine the issue sooner fairly than afterwards right before the upcoming presidential election. This scenario associated congressional redistricting, but the independent state legislature doctrine is as applicable to redistricting as it is to presidential elections.

The Republicans are also in the throes of electing Trump-endorsed candidates to state legislative offices in crucial swing states, setting up into office environment their favored point out election officers who deny that Biden gained the 2020 election, these kinds of as secretaries of condition, electing sympathetic condition courtroom judges onto the condition benches and grooming their favored prospective electors for ultimate variety by the party, all so they will be positioned to generate and transmit option electoral slates to Congress, if need be.

Ultimately, they are furiously politicking to elect Trump supporters to the Senate and Household, so they can overturn the election in Congress, as a very last resort.

Forewarned is to be forearmed.

Trump and the Republicans can only be stopped from stealing the 2024 election at this point if the Supreme Court docket rejects the independent condition legislature doctrine (thus permitting point out courtroom enforcement of point out constitutional constraints on legislatively enacted election regulations and elector appointments) and Congress amends the Electoral Count Act to constrain Congress’ possess electric power to reject condition electoral votes and choose the presidency.

Opinion: Utah Senate race could hold the key to breaking political polarization

While the Vice President will be a Democrat in 2024, both equally parties also want to enact federal legislation that expressly limitations the vice president’s electric power to be coextensive with the electricity accorded the vice president in the 12th Modification and confirm that it is mainly ceremonial, as Pence construed it to be on January 6.

Vice President Kamala Harris would preside above the Joint Session in 2024. Neither Democrats nor Republicans have any idea who will be presiding after that, having said that. As a result, equally get-togethers have the incentive to explain the vice president’s ceremonial position now.

As it stands these days, Trump, or his anointed successor, and the Republicans are poised, in their term, to “steal” from Democrats the presidential election in 2024 that they falsely declare the Democrats stole from them in 2020. But there is a big difference concerning the falsely claimed “stolen” election of 2020 and what would be the stolen election of 2024. Compared with the Democrats’ theft claimed by Republicans, the Republicans’ theft would be in open up defiance of the well-known vote and as a result the will of the American folks: poetic, while tragic, irony for America’s democracy.